Trans Media Update

Trans flag

Quick reports on four news stories from the last week.

The Transphobic Two-Step – the TERFS and the Right-Wing Press

On Monday the Times ran a report (paywall) headlined Youth Hostels Association allow trans guests to use female dormitories. Now, since the Equality Act became law in 2010, an organisation which excludes trans women from women’s facilities or trans men from men’s facilities (because trans men exist too, you know) is breaking the law unless they have a good reason. Regardless of this, the right-wing press and TERF activists have now got a technique for generating transphobic non-stories down pat. You find an organisation that is trans-inclusive – which is easy, because the law means they all are. Then you get a few women to express “outrage” – which is also easy, with TERFs knocking round on Twitter – and that’s your story written. You can do one of these a week till the cows come home, framing each one as “political correctness gone mad”.

Trans People Exist Shock Horror

If the Times’ technique is new, the Mail is sticking with a good old fashioned outing just like the 1980s never ended. Saturday saw the publication of Revealed: THREE soldiers from the same Army base who were born male change their gender after being given full backing from commanders. This had all the classic features – deadnaming, misgendering, before-and-after photos and prurient speculation about surgery. And, of course, no justification at all. Trans people in the army – what next? Black people?

Still No Gender Clinic in Wales

Transphobes frequently talk about a “powerful trans lobby”, but the truth is that many trans people still can’t access the health care they need. Back in January the BBC reported that no gender identity clinic existed in Wales – Welsh people were having to travel to London after two years on a waiting list. Plans for a clinic had existed since August 2017, but Welsh GPs were saying they had no confidence it would meet people’s needs. Nine months later, there is still no clinic. Even after trans people have seen the London clinic, many Welsh GPs are failing to write the prescriptions which the clinic has said they need. Meanwhile, last Friday, the BBC reported that Dr Helen Webberley, who ran an online GP service used by Welsh trans people, has been convicted of breaching the Care Standards Act. This is part of a longstanding pattern where the NHS fails to provide services, while doctors with more accepting attitudes are condemned for breaching “professional standards”. As Ruth Pearce puts it, if people don’t like what Helen Webberley is doing, what action are they taking to make health care available?

The Myth of Young People Being Coerced into Transitioning

Transphobic campaigners claim that young people are being encouraged to transition even though they aren’t really trans at all. From their accounts, you’d think services for young trans people could be accessed at the drop of a hat. Nothing could be further from the truth. There is one clinic in Britain working with young people with gender issues. Before they are referred, young people need to access their local CAMHS (Child and Adolescent Mental Health Services), which adds 6 months to the 18 months they can expect to spend waiting for a first appointment at the Gender Identity Service. As highlighted last week by campaigner Growing Up Trans, three young people in the care of the service have died by suicide since 2016: in at least two of these cases failures by the service are implicated. In one case, a young person had been waiting so long that the initial appointment would have happened after their 18th birthday – so they were told they would need to start all over again, get referred to adult services and spend years more on a different waiting list. Official papers state that “A letter was sent to the young person and their family explaining this… Sadly, the young person  committed suicide and the Gender Identity Service letter was found in the young person’s bedroom.” Gay Star News reported last Thursday that almost 1 in 7 trans teenagers in the US has attempted suicide. Access to health care for young trans people in Britain needs to be massively improved.

Book review – Reiche: Sexuality and Class Struggle

Sexualität und Klassenkampf cover

Several months ago, a few of us working around Marxism and sexuality discovered the publication, in 1970, of a book titled Sexuality and the Class Struggle, by Reimut Reiche. We were intrigued. Here was a book, apparently from the height of the radicalisation of the 1960s, which dealt with these issues from a Marxist perspective. Yet none of us had heard of it. Why had it vanished from view? This piece is an attempt to answer that question – if you like, a brief book review of a text published almost fifty years ago.

Reiche’s book was published in English, by Verso, in 1970. However, this text was translated from a German version written in the winter of 1967-68 (the image above shows the German mass-market paperback edition). How this fits with the chronology of the period is of key importance: the book essentially predates the development of the Women’s Liberation and Gay Liberation movements. For example, the protest at the Miss America beauty contest, which did much to raise awareness of women’s liberation in the US and internationally, took place in September 1968, while the Stonewall riots happened in June 1969. Now, these events didn’t come out of nothing. Drag queens/trans women had already fought the cops in the Compton’s Cafeteria Riot of August 1966 in the Tenderloin district of San Francisco, and activists were referring the same year to the notion of “gay power”. Initial organisation of women’s groups started in 1967– a publication from the spring of 1968 was entitled “Notes from the First Year”. The politics of both these movements reflected those of the much larger and better established movement for civil rights/black power. They took for granted that the fight against oppression was, centrally, the task of oppressed groups themselves – this, largely because of the sexism and homophobia of much of the American left at the time – and rooted their political practice in personal experience.

Reiche thus had the misfortune to write a book about sexuality just before some of the key events took place which have shaped left understanding of these issues since. He is also writing before the completely unexpected explosion of May 1968, when students raised barricades in the centre of Paris and a general strike caused the French president, Charles de Gaulle, to temporarily flee the country to Germany. The question facing the left became “revolution is on the agenda – how should we take it forward?” But before then, the question through the 1950s and 60s had been “workers aren’t fighting – they seem to have been bought off by the spread of consumer goods like fridges and washing machines – how should the left respond?”

This is the political context in which Reiche finds himself: a few student struggles have happened, but most young workers desire to be “respectable” and reject students as “layabouts”. He turns, for an account of sexuality and of society more generally, to the ideas of Herbert Marcuse, hugely influential in the 1960s. The Frankfurt School, to which Marcuse belonged, had initially developed in Germany between the wars, and had sought to explain why workers were not doing more to fight capitalism and in particular fascism. They developed an account of society which combined the ideas of Marx and Freud, and suggested that workers didn’t oppose the bosses or the Nazis because many of them found some subconscious gratification in acceptance of elements of capitalism or fascism. After the Nazi seizure of power members of the school were exiled to America, and here they developed a similar analysis of 1950s consumerism, which they found similar in some ways to German fascism. In this view, workers were getting enough satisfaction from American capitalism that they would not fight back. This is very much how Reiche talks of 1960s Germany – indeed, he describes the German ruling class as almost infinitely capable of manipulating workers’ thinking, via advertising and the media, to suit its own needs.

If there is little we can do to change the world, at least we can understand it, and describe how things could be better. Here Reiche relies on a Freudian account of the development of sexuality through oral, anal, phallic and genital stages. What Marx there is in the book comes mostly via Marcuse and Wilhelm Reich, but there is a great deal more Freud. Socialism, Reiche suggests, will be characterised in Freudian terms by the disappearance of the superego as regards society in general, and the typically achievement of “full genitality” when it comes to sex. Homosexuality will be accepted, but perversions, however defined, will die out. What does this mean in practice in the Germany of 1968? Reiche opposes utopian attempts to institute communal living, where people try to free themselves from bourgeois ideas about sex while capitalism remains completely dominant – for example, by rejecting monogamy. Yet it’s unclear what practical alternative he proposes, and his method seems strangely abstract, compared to the approaches rooted in personal experience which we’re now used to.

None of this is to reject Sexuality and Class Struggle completely. Reiche repeatedly refers, for example, to Marcuse’s concept of “repressive desublimation” – rather than seeking to repress sexuality as they had earlier, in this view, the ruling class made certain commodified forms of sex more available so as to win workers’ acceptance of capitalism. It’s a view that it would be interesting to reassess in the light of the even greater commodification of sexuality we’ve seen in the last fifty years. But the basic problem of Reiche’s writing is that it was written before the world, quite unpredictably and dramatically, changed so that his book is now more of historical interest than anything else.

From Borough Poly to a Biscuit Tin: Queer Art at Tate Britain

The exhibition “Queer British Art” at Tate Britain highlights the many different ways LGBT people have made art, and made liveable lives for themselves 
(until 1 October, details here)

At the point when I came across Noel Coward’s dressing gown in a glass case, I had my doubts about Queer British Art. I’d already seen sentimental Victorian versions of ancient Greece, portraits of famous forebears and now a famous thespian’s clothing. Had the curators just gathered together any old thing related to LGBT people and put it on show? And there may be some element of that. But there’s still something important and deeply moving about this somewhat random collection of artworks and mementos.

Read moreFrom Borough Poly to a Biscuit Tin: Queer Art at Tate Britain

Saint with a blue dress on: a footnote from queer history

St Jerome in a blue dress

A fifteenth-century prayer book shows bearded father of the church St Jerome wearing the clothing you’d associate with a noblewoman. What’s going on?

Around 1400 Jean de Berry, a French nobleman, commissioned a sumptuously illustrated prayer book, the Belles Heures, today recognised as a masterpiece of its period. One of its illustrations concerns Saint Jerome, one of the most respected of saints. The illustration is in two parts. On the right, Jerome sleeps in a small room while another monk carries a garment of bright blue, a striking contrast with the dull colours of the monk’s habit and the blankets on Jerome’s bed. Then, in the image on the left, Jerome – identified by his beard and saintly halo – is wearing the blue garment in the chapel. It turns out to be the kind of dress women in this period wore, with a tight waist and sleeves and a full, trailing skirt. Two monks seem to be having a conversation about what Jerome is doing, and are possibly laughing at him.

Read moreSaint with a blue dress on: a footnote from queer history

Review: Guapa by Saleem Haddad

Author Saleem Haddad

Guapa is the story of Rasa, a young man in an unnamed Arab country. In the first pages he awakens to recall the disastrous night before, when his grandmother caught him in bed with another man in the apartment he shares with her. How men who love other men make lives for themselves in Middle Eastern countries is inseparable in the novel, however, from wider social and political questions. Rasa has been involved in huge protests against the dictatorial president as part of his country’s Arab Spring. For a short, optimistic period real freedom seemed possible. But the decline of those protests has left behind it a choice between the regime and an Islamist opposition, both repressive in their different ways.

Read moreReview: Guapa by Saleem Haddad

Why I’m not celebrating the fall of Keith Vaz

Keith Vaz


I never thought I would feel the slightest sympathy for Keith Vaz. The parliamentary watchdog twice found he had received money without declaring it; he was sacked over his relationship with the wealthy Hinduja brothers; he was suspended from parliament for making false allegations about a woman who had accused him of corruption; and he claimed tens of thousands in expenses for a Westminster flat when he lived 45 minutes away in Stanmore. If you want to know why so many people hold politicians in contempt, you have only to look at Vaz’s career.

But Vaz has fallen not over (alleged) corruption, but over sex with two East European escorts who also supplied poppers – “the sex-enhancing drug used by gay men” as the Guardian helpfully explains to its readers. Now, maybe we should think of this as the exposure of a cynical, hypocritical individual who pretended respectability. There’s a pleasure in possessing the moral high ground – I’ve already seen a friend of a friend on Facebook taking the view that she could never feel any sympathy for someone who bought sex.

Read moreWhy I’m not celebrating the fall of Keith Vaz

Beatriz Preciado – Testo Junkie

Testo Junkie book cover

Beatriz Preciado, Testo Junkie: Sex, Drugs and Biopolitics in the Pharmacopornographic Era, Feminist Press, New York, £16.99 (Amazon Kindle edition £6.47)

Testo Junkie addresses its theme – sex, drugs and biopolitics – in two ways. The first is autobiographical, Preciado’s account of her life as she takes testosterone, in the form of a gel applied to the skin. This she does without medical supervision, since she isn’t interested in transitioning, in going through what she sees as a medically defined process through which she rejects her female identity. So the doses of testosterone are low – not enough to cause “masculinisation” such as facial hair. This is an experiment, to test or play with her identity as a woman, to examine its boundaries. She is, in her phrase, a “gender hacker”. She writes:

I do not want the female gender that has been assigned to me at birth. Neither do I want the male gender that transsexual medicine can furnish and that the state will award me if I behave in the right way. I don’t want any of it.

Read moreBeatriz Preciado – Testo Junkie

Audre Lorde – Zami: A New Spelling of My Name

zamiPublished in 1982, Zami is a memoir by Audre Lorde, the black feminist lesbian writer. Lorde died of cancer in 1992, having gained a position of great respect in the 1980s women’s movement for her writing about the overlapping issues of race, gender and sexuality which had formed the context for her own life. As I recall, while the word “intersectionality” wasn’t used back then, these were live issues – there existed a Gay Black Group and a Gay Lesbian Group which met at Gay’s the Word bookshop.

Read moreAudre Lorde – Zami: A New Spelling of My Name